Authors: Jay L. Devore
ISBN-13: 978-1305251809
See our solution for Question 37E from Chapter 8 from Devore's Probability and Statistics for Engineering and Science.
The data on cube compressive strength (MPa) of concrete specimens is given.
a.
A probability plot is constructed by plotting X- strength against its corresponding Z-score.
\[Z = \frac{{X - \bar X}}{{{s_X}}}\]Where,
$\bar X$ is the sample mean.
${S_{\bar X}}$ is sample standard deviation.
The sample mean $\bar X$ for the given data is obtained as:
\[\begin{array}{c} \bar X = \frac{{\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{10} {{X_i}} }}{{10}}\\ = \frac{{964.2}}{{10}}\\ = 96.42 \end{array}\]The sample standard deviation ${S_{\bar X}}$ is obtained as:
\[\begin{array}{c} {S_{\bar X}} = \sqrt {\frac{{\sum\limits_{i = 1}^{10} {{X_i} - \bar X} }}{{n - 1}}} \\ = \sqrt {\frac{{613}}{9}} \\ = 8.258 \end{array}\]Data is tabulated as shown below:
| X | Z |
| 112.3 | 1.922851 |
| 97 | 0.07023 |
| 92.7 | -0.45044 |
| 86 | -1.26172 |
| 102 | 0.675662 |
| 99.2 | 0.33662 |
| 95.8 | -0.07507 |
| 103.5 | 0.857291 |
| 89 | -0.89846 |
| 86.7 | -1.17696 |
Normal probability plot is constructed by plotting X observation in vertical axis and its corresponding z score on horizontal axis as shown:

This plot shows straight line relationship between the sample points.
Therefore, it is plausible that the compressive strength is normally distributed.
b.
Let the true average strength be denoted by $\mu$.
The hypothesis are formulated as:
The null hypothesis:
\[{H_0}:\mu = 100\]That is, average strength is 100MPa.
VS
The alternative hypothesis:
\[{H_1}:\mu < 100\]That is, average strength is less than 100MPa.
The test statistics used is one sample T,
\[t = \frac{{\bar x - {\mu _0}}}{{\frac{s}{{\sqrt n }}}}\]Here, ${\mu _0}$ is the value of strength considered in null hypothesis.
Substituting the values and obtaining the value of test statistics,
\[\begin{array}{c} t = \frac{{96.42 - 100}}{{\frac{{8.258}}{{\sqrt {10} }}}}\\ = \frac{{ - 3.58}}{{2.611}}\\ = - 1.37 \end{array}\]The P-value for the two tailed test (using t-table) is obtained as:
\[\begin{array}{c} p - value = 2P\left( {t \ge |{t_{cal}}|} \right)\\ = 2P\left( {t \ge 1.37} \right)\\ = 2 \times \left( {1 - P\left( {t < 1.37} \right)} \right)\\ = 0.102 \end{array}\]The p-value is 0.102.
For, $\alpha = 0.05$,
\[P - value\left( {0.102} \right) > \alpha \left( {0.05} \right)\]That is, the p-value is greater than the level of significance.
Therefore, by rejection rule, fail to reject the null hypothesis and it can be concluded that true average strength is 100 MPa.